Zatanna vs Scarlet Witch

[Gary]

Since the Superman vs Thor debate seems to be nearing an end, I thought I'd set up the next one.

Fishnets vs Headdress. Who wins?

[Agent X]

Originally posted by Gary
Since the Superman vs Thor debate seems to be nearing an end, I thought I'd set up the next one.

Fishnets vs Headdress. Who wins?

If this was the original conception of Zatanna I would give it to her but since it isn't what people are thinking about: Scarlet Witch.

[Hermit]

To this day, I am sheepishly ashamed that my favorite amalgram from the DC vs Marvel series was "The White Witch". It was like Mae West of the mystic set. I know it was my inner juvenile that liked her, but I couldn't help it.

[Agent X]

Originally posted by Hermit
To this day, I am sheepishly ashamed that my favorite amalgram from the DC vs Marvel series was "The White Witch". It was like Mae West of the mystic set. I know it was my inner juvenile that liked her, but I couldn't help it.

I like any woman who will tell me that when they're good they're great but when they're bad they're better.

[Glen Sprigg]

I'll go with Zatanna; she has more experience as a sorceress than Wanda. Wanda's got her hex powers, yes, but Zatanna can simply do a lot more.

Glen

[Lord Liaden]

Originally posted by Glen Sprigg
I'll go with Zatanna; she has more experience as a sorceress than Wanda. Wanda's got her hex powers, yes, but Zatanna can simply do a lot more.

Glen

Can't speak to the very latest version of Zatanna, but with her probability-altering powers much more under her control, there's very little that the Scarlet Witch can't currently do.

More to the point, can Zatanna perform a Transian gypsy folk dance that'll boost your blood pressure? I think not!

[Superskrull]

Despite the attraction of fishnet stockings, I'm going with the homo sapiens superior over the homo sapiens magi. Zatanna might have had and possibly even been regaining her old "Anything Goes" level of magic but Wanda can slap reality around and call it 'Susan' if she wants. She has a decent level of training, aptitude and experience wielding magic and it stacks good with her mutant power of changing reality by wiggling her fingers at it. She's the one who's capable of having babies with an android and bringing back her dead boyfriend from the twin dooms of becoming one with the ionosphere and having his comic cancelled.

[Nucleon]

I don't know too much about Zatanna. Does she still have that backward words transformation magic? If she has, that would make her more in control of her juju, while Scarlet Witch effects, althought more powerful, seems quite random. She tends to tire fast, too.

I give the edge to the Witch in the end, because of her Avenger hand-to-hand training. She seems a more well-rounded character.

Ooops.

[MisterVimes]

Originally posted by Superskrull
Despite the attraction of fishnet stockings, I'm going with the homo sapiens superior over the homo sapiens magi.

Now THERE is a man with a memory... I thought I was the only one who remembered that Homo Magi storyline in JLA...

[MisterVimes]

I think it comes down to potentials (sort of like Hulk vs Supes)... DC characters (whihc I love dearly) have sort of a set 'cap' that establishes what they can and cannot do... Marvel (especially in the case with a power as vague as the HEX) seems to have an open-ended expansion of power... That's why I gave it to wanda. The Hex power controls probability and, eventually, that's gonna get you...

[Big Willy]

Zee versus Wanda...

In mud...

With a nice shower afterwards...

Ahem.

[MisterVimes]

Originally posted by Big Willy
Zee versus Wanda...

In mud...

With a nice shower afterwards...

Ahem.

Now there's a visual

[winterhawk]

One word...fishnets

[MisterVimes]

Originally posted by winterhawk
One word...fishnets

Ah... but wanda in the bodice.... *drool*

[Chaosliege]

I don't realy know a lot about Zatanna, but I do know how powerful SW is. I give it to her.