Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: Alien Eclipse Tourism

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    Somewhere in Idaho . . .
    Age
    31
    Posts
    1,104
    Rep Power
    3089317

    Alien Eclipse Tourism

    There's this movie pitch that asserts that
    1. More air travel is used for tourism than business (not sure if this is true, unless you count going to visit family as tourism)
    2. Aliens would have better tech advances, such that they would find space travel is as easy as we find air travel. (insert anal probe joke here. Seriously though, I'm not confident there are any sentient aliens, and seriously doubt FTL travel is possible, and I doubt anybody will spend 10,000 years on ice for tourism purposes)
    3. Our solar eclipses are interesting and unusual in the galaxy, because they require
      1. a planet with a reasonably clear atmosphere and other conditions that would let an alien stand on it and do tourism activities, even if it has to do them in a hawiian print space suit
      2. a moon just exactly the right size and distance from the planet and a sun that is just exactly the right size and distance from the planet that they appear to be the same size from a planetary observer.

    It's this last criteria that he thinks is super rare, and so aliens will come to see it, because it is one of those strange celestial phenomena that Kirk was always investigating. And he wants to make a movie about it. The full pitch is spoilered below, because it is long.
    Spoiler:


    Anyway, I'm not sure that point of his about perfect eclipses is correct. He claims that either the Moon or the Star would usually appear to be much larger/smaller than the other, and so you wouldn't get the cool eclipses you see on earth. I find this suspicious. Can any astronomy buffs clarify how rare this phenomena is suspected to be?

    I will say that I hope it isn't a galactic tourist attraction. So near as I can tell, Humans just don't like tourists. Even when their livelyhood depends on them, they view them as stupid, problem generating beasts. Filling the Earth with them would cause all kinds of headaches.
    My Flickr stream

    Please read "The Emergency State" by David Unger. It's a history of US foreign policy in the last hundred years, and I thought it was amazing.

    Never express yourself more clearly than you are able to think
    --Niels Bohr

    I am the one true Sociotard

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Location
    Perth
    Posts
    1,630
    Rep Power
    2319855

    Re: Alien Eclipse Tourism

    Well, it's not the only place in the solar system where a moon blots out the sun - the 4 big satellites of Jupiter cast visible shadows in the cloud tops, and I'm pretty sure we've got photos of Phobo's shadow on Mars. No doubt Titan and the other large moons of the outer solar system eclipse the sun even more easily, since, of course, the sun is an even tinier disc out there.

    But Earth IS the only place in the solar system where the satellite is an almost exact match for the diameter of the solar disc - but even then, not at *every* eclipse - hence Annular Eclipses. And a large moon, around a small rocky planet, is a little unusual - the formation of our moon required a quite unlikely-seeming glancing blow from a Mars-sized protoplanet.
    Why did the chicken cross the road?

    He was giving it the Last Rites.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Sexsmith, Alberta, Canada
    Posts
    2,282
    Blog Entries
    9
    Rep Power
    2133923

    Re: Alien Eclipse Tourism

    Quote Originally Posted by Sociotard View Post
    Anyway, I'm not sure that point of his about perfect eclipses is correct. He claims that either the Moon or the Star would usually appear to be much larger/smaller than the other, and so you wouldn't get the cool eclipses you see on earth. I find this suspicious. Can any astronomy buffs clarify how rare this phenomena is suspected to be?
    No other object in the solar system has a moon of the right size to block out the sun but not the corona at their distance from it. It would require a rather precise concurrence of apparent sizes.
    And don't worry, everyone, Hawkeye is back, ready to shoot an arrow at something in case we run out of bullets!


    Cracked.com

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Germany
    Age
    28
    Posts
    5,316
    Rep Power
    2088142

    Re: Alien Eclipse Tourism

    Quote Originally Posted by Clonus View Post
    No other object in the solar system has a moon of the right size to block out the sun but not the corona at their distance from it. It would require a rather precise concurrence of apparent sizes.
    And these things won't be in that relation forever:
    "This means that hundreds of millions of years ago the Moon would always completely cover the Sun on solar eclipses, and no annular eclipses were possible. Likewise, about 600 million years from now (if the angular diameter of the Sun does not change), the Moon will no longer cover the Sun completely, and only annular eclipses will occur.[104]"- From Wikipedia.

    When you add in otehr factors, like "needs to ahve an Atmosphere" or "sun needs to be a Yellow Dwarf, spectrall class G2V" then our planet could be very much the nearest one with that correlation.
    Of coruse you could fake such an eclipse effect by just taking a moon wiht somewhat smaller relative diameter and jsut park your ship closer to it, but that would be cheating...
    Quote Originally Posted by prestidigitator View Post
    If it looks like a duck, and sounds like a duck, it might just be a duck-flavored Killing Attack
    Are you stuck in Mobile Style and want to go back? Look here:
    http://www.herogames.com/forums/show...43#post2159343

  5. #5
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    RA 8h 50.4m, Dec +11 49
    Age
    55
    Posts
    3,080
    Rep Power
    4571311

    Re: Alien Eclipse Tourism

    What with the first week of classes being just about over, and it taking me about four times as long to write the script as it should have with all the d***ed interruptions, it took a week plus to get to this.

    I grabbed all the Solar System planet and moon data out of Wikipedia and did a brute-force check, computing the minimum and maximum angular radii of the Sun as seen from each planet's equator, and then the angular radius of all the moons, again as seen from the equator of the planet.

    I figured that if the moon's angular radius is in that range of possible solar angular radii, then that moon is close enough to the angular size of the Sun (as seen from the planet) that the "total eclipse" aesthetic should apply.

    I get more than one hit.

    Of course, Earth's Moon is a hit. Its angular radius is 948 arc seconds, the Sun's ranges from 943 to 975.

    Pandora, a moon of Saturn, is a hit. Its angular radius is 103 arc seconds; the angular radius of the Sun as seen from Saturn ranges from 95 to 106 arc seconds. Saturn's orbital period is 29.46 years, but its axial tilt is only 2.4 degrees, so without working anything out carefully, my guess is there would be lots of eclipses in clutches separated by decade-long gaps with none.

    S/2011 P 1, a satellite of Pluto announced last summer, is one hit. Pluto has a pretty eccentric orbit, with the Sun's angular radius varying between 19.6 to 32.3 arc seconds; if the size of the satellite is to be accepted (seems premature), then the satellite has an angular radius of 23.2 arc seconds. However ... the whole Pluto system is tipped by about 120 degrees, so Pluto would have a series of such eclipses (each about 32 Earth days apart) lasting a couple of Earth decades twice a plutonian year (248 Earth years).

    Now ... what's all that say about the rarity of the eclipse esthetic the "ad" was purporting? Well ... until we know more about the frequency of real earthlike planets, I don't think a lot can be said, but I think it takes some of the edge off the rarity argument. It might influence your decision about when to visit Earth once you'd already decided to visit, but I doubt it's a unique enough phenomenon to draw the whole galaxy.

    BTW, not on topic ... there'll be an annular eclipse of interest to lots of HERO board folks on 20 May. Path of maximum eclipse comes ashore on the southern coast of Oregon, and proceeds southwestward, with the Moon's shadow losing contact with Earth when it's over central Texas. Add to that, the transit of Venus on June 5 (US date), and it's an excellent year for naked-eye phenomena.
    ... abnormal, non-Euclidean, and loathsomely redolent of spheres and dimensions apart from ours.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Germany
    Age
    28
    Posts
    5,316
    Rep Power
    2088142

    Re: Alien Eclipse Tourism

    Since Pluto doesn't counts as Planet anymore and you have trouble standing on Saturn (unless your name is "Cloudwalker" and you deserve it), earth is still the only planet in our solar system
    Quote Originally Posted by prestidigitator View Post
    If it looks like a duck, and sounds like a duck, it might just be a duck-flavored Killing Attack
    Are you stuck in Mobile Style and want to go back? Look here:
    http://www.herogames.com/forums/show...43#post2159343

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Grond + Eclipse = 2 Gronds?
    By Dr Archeville in forum Champions
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: Apr 29th, '08, 01:38 PM
  2. Eclipse Power
    By d'Jarvish in forum HERO System Discussion
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: Sep 17th, '04, 01:05 PM
  3. Champions (Eclipse Comics)
    By SCUBA Hero in forum Champions
    Replies: 15
    Last Post: May 12th, '03, 12:53 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •