Jump to content

The Master List Superdraft Poll

Choose Three (3) on each  

9 members have voted

This poll is closed to new votes
  1. 1. Best Contribution to the Master List

    • Cancer
    • csyphrett
    • death tribble
    • Dr. MID-Nite
    • Hermit
    • Old Man
    • Pariah
    • Psybolt
    • Sociotard
  2. 2. Best Final Draft

    • Downwind from Hell
    • Tin Trouble at Tesladyne
    • Independence for Sale
    • God Save the Queen
    • City of Light, City of Glass
    • The Bachelor Hunger Games Saturday Morning Cartoon Power Hour
    • Sin City Avengers
    • I Remember ...
    • Operation: Plant Extraction

  • Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.
  • Poll closed on 05/01/2020 at 07:00 AM

Recommended Posts

Thanks to all for participating in my draft, and making it the success it was. Please even if you didn't participate, join in the poll! We had some clever picks, some good fanfiction, and its the least recognition their work deserves. Note that the unique format of this draft called for two different polls: one for best contribution to the Master List, one for best final draft selection.


Best Contribution

Green Goblin
Martian Manhunter 
Orion Slave Girls
Prostetnik Vogon Jeltz 
Razzberry Lizard

Baron Blood 
Gabriel Van Helsing 
The Gemini Man 
The Human Bomb 
The Spectre

death tribble
Brainiac 5
Coda Assassin
Karate Kid
Shadow Lass

Dr. MID-Nite
Emerald Empress
Radioactive Man
Sub Mariner

Alfred Pennyworth 
Blue Beetle
Dr. Doom
Green Lantern
Mary Jane Watson

Old Man
Dr. Octopus
Granny Goodness
Miss America
Ms. Marvel
Omega Sentinel
Talia al Ghul 

Jack Frost
Kim Possible
Spirit of '76

Erica Slaughter
Ms. Marvel
The Tick 
Werewolf by Night 

Moon Knight
Plastic Man
Squirrel Girl

Best Completed Draft


Downwind from Hell

Location: Chernobyl Exclusion Zone

Character: Dr. Doom (Victor Von Doom)

Character: Looker (Emily Briggs)

Character: Radioactive Man (Chen Lu)

Character: Human Bomb (Andrew Franklin)

Character: She-Hulk (Jennifer Walters)

Character: Wendigo (Wendigo)

Character: The Gemini Man (Sam Casey)

Character: Karate Kid (Val Armorr)

Option: First of the Fallen (First of the Fallen | DC [Hellblazer villain])

Option: Horde (Horde | Marvel)

Option: Mimoths (Mimoths | from Girl Genius)


Tin Trouble at Tesladyne

Location: Tesladyne Island

Character: Grifter (Cole Cash)

Character: Zealot (Lady Zannah)

Character: Shego (Shego)

Character: Omega Sentinel (Karima Shapandar)

Character: Granny Goodness (Granny Goodness)

Character: Huck (Huck)

Character: Pike (Pike)

Character: Enchantress (Amora)

Option: Atomic Robo (Atomic Robo)

Option: Sentinels (Sentinels | Marvel [X-Men Villains])

Option: SD Gundam Force (Gundam)


Independence for Sale

Location: New York City

Character: Emerald Empress (Emerald Empress)

Character: Spider-man (Peter Parker)

Character: Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)

Character: Dr. Octopus (Olivia Octavius)

Character: Firestorm (Ronnie Raymond)

Character: Blue Beetle (Ted Kord)

Character: Bane (Bane)

Character: Martian Manhunter (J'onn J'onzz)

Option: Batman (Bruce Wayne)

Option: Persuader (Nyeun Chun Ti | DC [Fatal Five])

Option: Declaration of Independence (Historical Documentx)


God Save the Queen!

Location: London, England

Character: Wonder Woman (Diana Prince)

Character: Foxbat (Freddy Fosgood)

Character: Plastic Man (Patrick O'Brian)

Character: Mirage (Danielle Moonstar)

Character: Ginormica (Susan Murphy)

Character: Madcap (Madcap)

Character: Werewolf by Night (Jack Russell)

Character: Spirit of '76 (William Naslund)

Option: Galactus (Galactus | Marvel)

Option:  Exo Skeleton Man (Leroy McGowan | Champions)

Option: Centipede Mobile (Champions)


City of Light, City of Glass

Location: Paris, France

Character: Diamondback (Rachel Leighton)

Character: Superman (Clark Kent)

Character: Brainiac (Brainiac)

Character: Talia al Ghul (Talia al Ghul)

Character: Lobo (Lobo)

Character: Silk (Cindy Moon)

Character: Tundro (Tundro)

Character: Jack Frost (Rise of the Guardians)

Option: Kryptonite (DC Comics)

Option: The League of Assassins (DC Comics)

Option: Batroc the Leaper (Georges Batroc | Marvel)


The Bachelor Hunger Games Saturday Morning Cartoon Power Hour

Location: Panem

Character: Kim Possible (Kimberly Anne Possible)

Character: Mary Jane (Mary Jane)

Character: Erica Slaughter (Erica Slaughter)

Character: Squirrel Girl (Doreen Alene Green)

Character: Terra (Tara Markov)

Character: Shadow Lass (Tasmia Mallor)

Character: Prostetnik Vogon Jeltz (Prostetnik Vogon Jeltz)

Character: Coda Assassin (Coda Assassin)

Option: Mugatu (Jacobim Mugatu | Zoolander)

Option: Ruby Rhod (Ruby Rhod | The 5th Element)

Option: Joffrey Baratheon (Joffrey Baratheon | Game of Thrones)


Sin City Avengers

Location: Las Vegas, Nevada

Character: Moon Knight (Marc Spector)

Character: Spider-Woman (Gwen Stacy)

Character: Cloak (Tyrone Johnson)

Character: Dagger (Tandy Bowen)

Character: Ms. Marvel (Kamala Khan)

Character: Sinestro (Thaal Sinestro)

Character: Green Goblin (Norman Osborne)

Character: Solitaire (Nicholas Lone)

Option: The Kingpin (Wilson Fisk)

Option: Vic Fontaine (Vic Fontaine | Deep Space 9)

Option: Card Sharks (Card Shark Organization | Dark Champions)


I Remember ...

Location: The Alamo, San Antonio, Texas

Character: Gabriel Van Helsing (Van Helsing)

Character: Baron Blood (Johnathon Falsworth)

Character: Helspont (Artus of Daem)

Character: Alfred Pennyworth (Alfred Pennyworth)

Character: Blackhawk (Janos Prohaska)

Character: The Specter (Jim Corrigan)

Character: Brainiac (Querl Dox)

Character: Firearm (Alec Swan)

Option: Vampire Horde (from Vampire State Building)

Option: Daemonites (Daemonites | DC [Wild C.A.T.S enemy])

Option: Hugo Strange (Hugo Strange | DC)


Operation: Plant Extraction

Location: Monster Island

Character: Miss America (America Chavez)

Character: Orion Slave Girls (Orion Slave Girls)

Character: Man-Thing (Theodore Sallis)

Character: Voyd (Karen Fields)

Character: The Tick (Nick)

Character: Razzberry Lizard (Razzberry Lizard)

Character: Hulk (Bruce Banner)

Character: Sub-Mariner (Namor)

Option: Midnight Angels (Elite Dora Milaje)

Option: Aspen Matthews (Aspen Matthews | Fathom)

Option: Shanna the She-Devil (Shanna O'Hara | Marvel)+

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, Psybolt said:

Had to vote for csyphrett's list... I drafted 5 of them.


The second vote only allows one choice...by the way


I used my amazing mod powers to change  that. Though it might not have been needed as I see Sociotard is still on

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites



My contribution list was simple: "It's not easy being green."  Three heroes, three villains, two others.  Never dreamed that Hulk and Martian Manhunter would go so late.  Concept #3 was for a certain kind of offbeat characters that I hadn't been able to gel together at the time the starting gun went off.


Strangely, I had a solid concept for the beginning of a story arc despite a really peculiar assortment of characters, and a very clear picture of where it was supposed to end up.  Between those two points?  Overall, escalating weirdness and violence, and I figured two-three years of monthly comic books would be able to cover those bases, but I didn't have any profound intermediate scenes in mind when it came time to write the fiction.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm glad everyone had fun. I would like to do this again next year. I do think I should finesse the rules a bit. I nixed one player from submitting Elsa from Frozen, because I said she was more Fantasy than Superheroic, and now I think that was too restrictive. She certainly fit better than some of the comic book characters that were submitted.


But I have a year to figure out a better rubric.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Might put in a spot of breathing room: each participant submits (e.g.) a list of 9, while having to draft 8.


Alternately, list of 9, and only your last pick can come from your own list (and must, if any are remaining).

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Woot!  Tied for first in the comic line!  Yeah, I was totally smitten by the concept of Dr Doom ending up in the position of having to decide if he would literally accept a deal offer from the Devil.  Ending up tied with the Hunger Lust Saturday Morning Cheesecakes and Violence Parade is a signal honor.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tied for first in "Best Contribution to the Master List"? Huh. Did not see that coming. Thanks!


(I can't believe I finished ahead of It's Not Easy Being Green, though.)

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, people weren't impressed by Hulk and Martian Manhunter.  The latter was probably my #2 favorite back in the Silver Age in the early 1960s (#1 was The Flash -- Barry Allen -- as drawn by Carmine Infantino).

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Pariah said:

Tied for first in "Best Contribution to the Master List"? Huh. Did not see that coming. Thanks!


(I can't believe I finished ahead of It's Not Easy Being Green, though.)


Props to you co-top contributer!


For me, I think I have to thank Dr. Mid-nite, gave me the inspiration for the rest. 


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Create New...