Re: WWYCD: The Nightmare on Hero Street
Punchline is scarier than The Nightmare, which is a good thing. He would suppress The Nightmare's PRE until it was -30, and chase him down while he screams like a girl. He'd certainly try his BOECV entangle, and assuming that worked, he could find out whose nightmare it really was, after all.
In short: Kick his ass and take his wallet dreamside, then find him meatside and repeat same.
The Black Cat: Fights hard, dies anyway, I suspect. His curse might help him, but that's only a maybe. His luck might help him, but that's only a maybe, too.