Jump to content

Ivan

HERO Member
  • Posts

    55
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Ivan

  1. Re: Jedi and evil actions

     

    Just to play a little devils advocate, but shouldent social norms be taken into account. To use a non SW refrence there was a story were one member of a certain orginzation, after killing his opponent was preparing to eat him. Of course the other members of the group were horrified by this and the perp was mystified as to why. Turns out that the society he was from consuming a defeated enemy was a way to honor that enemy an ensure that at least some small part of him remained. (Extra points to anyone who can name the group and character.) So, if a Jedi comes from a society where killing prisioners was common place(fight or die, we give no quarter) would his not even trying to stop the killing be evil?

     

     

    As an aside, I was playing the bounty hunter in the above situation, and I agree that the GM was being an hathat.

  2. Re: Jedi and evil actions

     

    Let me clarify one point, the GM was not saying that any evil in the galaxy, his point was an evil act in close proxcimity to the Jedi. The argument was that the attempt, sucsessful or not was enough. The GM's piont was that the Jedi had not prevented said act when it took place in the near area.

  3. OK, a few years ago I was involved in a WEG Star Wars game when a huge contrversy croped up.

     

    With out going going in to to much detale; Jedi character became aware of another PC about to perform an evil act. Due to the situition in game said Jedi was unable to prevent the other PC from taking this action(in this case excuting a prisioner the Jedi tried to prevent the bounty hunter from doing this.) GM threatened to give jedi a dark side point, because he let an evil action take place. An argument ensued, the Jedi player saying that he had tried to prevent the killing and that intent should be enough.

     

    So whos side do you come down on the Jedi, because he attempted to stop evil, or the GM the very act tainting taking place in the Jedis presece tainting his soul.

     

    I figure with the collected wisdom on these boards we should get a good debate out of this.

  4. Re: IQ a give away

     

    Its cheap

     

    be strong and a genius

     

    yeay 5th

     

    SERIOUS DISCUSCION INVITED

     

    Why is int so lowly prised

     

    It may just be me, and it is totaly off topic, but does this feel like a trolling(is that a word?) post to anyone else?

     

    What I mean is, after his initial post Mr. Vorsch has not added anythig to this thread.

     

    Whats more the comment " yeay 5th" is really out of place as all the editions of Hero, going all the way back to to the blak and white cover, have had INT costing 1/1.

     

    Like I said it may just be me and if I am wrong my apologies in advance.

  5. Re: Pros/Cons of an 'official' campaign world

     

    Are you being serious? If you really want to use those characters -- take the hour or so it would take to update them to 5th edition and do it yourself. Frankly' date=' I suspect you could use them as written up and no one would notice that you hadn't updated them unless your players expect you to provide them with full write-ups on all the villains you use so they know that you were being rules-compliant.[/quote']

     

    Of course I was not serious. I should realize sarcasm(sp?) does not convey well over the internet. I just picked the worst characters i could think of to try and make a point. DOJ only has an obligation to produce quality work, not fill requests of "I want these characters and only these" I mean if I want an update of Shamrock than I will built it, not whine to Steve saying how unfair it is that they have not given us an update of him. "Oh, and while your at it I have this really kickin idea for a zombie ninja sorcer half orc/half demon, could you guys whip up an official write up for me?" (scarcasm again). I am an adult and I do not need anyone to hold my hand when it comes to building characters. Spelling maybe but not building.

  6. Re: Pros/Cons of an 'official' campaign world

     

    Well I happen to agree with FOX.

    I mean how dare they take already published characters away from the public like that. And they have been doing it for years. From the the original enemies books we are still missing Frisbee, Ultraviolet, Dart, Orb, and Diamond. This is a wholy indefensible move on the part of Steve and all the others at DOJ. We want the Geo-desics(sp) back!!!!

×
×
  • Create New...