Hey Steve,
Ok - so I have this power (this is an example - I don't actually have this power):
"French Fry of Doom."
It allows to take any french fry and use it to zap someone with hot oil.
I buy it as:
6d EB special effect: hot oil
Focus: any french fry
So I can pick up any french fry and out pours hot oil.
Now the focus limitation is as such:
OAF: Any French Fry
Durability: unbreakable
Does this mean that any french fry I pick up and use as a focus is unbreakable?
If it was:
OAF: Any French Fry
Durability: breakable
Then the french fry would have a minimum DEF of 3? (The DEF would actually be 6 because a 6d EB is 30 active points/5 = 6 DEF).
Now logically, that makes no sense but I can't find anything about it in the rules. We've houseruled it to be the same as a regular french fry (so basically "fragile" even if it was bought "unbreakable"). Basically, if you choose a single french fry as your focus (Ie. "The Magic French Fry of Ronald" is my focus) then it can be unbreakable. If it's "any french fry" then it's just a normal fry (and should probably be fragile) regardless of what the focus limitation says. This makes sense to me on some level, but strictly according to the focus rules, it would seem that if I made the focus "unbreakable" then any french fry I pick up to use as a focus would then be unbreakable.
Is there anything in the rules that I am simply missing? Is any french fry used as a focus considered unbreakable if it's a focus and bought as unbreakable? If I then drop the french fry to the ground, it now becomes breakable? I realize I can make it fragile, but what if instead of a french fry I used a sword? (IE. "with any sword in my hand, I can launch a 6d fireball" instead of "this sword launches fireballs" - is the sword unbreakable even if it's "any sword"?). Or how about "any image of a sword" - so it could be an image on paper (fragile?) , or an image carved into diamond (unbreakable?)...
I am fairly certain that the GM should force the player to buy "fragile" if he chose the "any french fry" focus, and that's that. But my GM currently says that even if the focus is bought as unbreakable, if it's defined as "any french fry" then it is just a normal fry, regardless that the focus is "unbreakable".
Thanks in advance.
Nox