Hi, I'm a GM for Champions campaign and I need some help in settling a rules dispute.
I have player in my game who is making a brick character who has a weaker, smaller teenage form. (Your basic Billy Batson / Capt Marvel deal)
Now, the way I understand it, a character can use Multiform to simulate this (effectively creating two different characters) ...
**OR**
purchase all the superhuman powers and characteristics as OIHID (When not in "super" form, our hero loses all the OIHID powers and becomes "normal")
Pretty straightforward so far right??
He sat down at my PC and used my HeroDesigner to make the character.
He used the Multiform option.
So I began looking over Brutus (the heroic form) and Virgil ( the normal form)
Apparently Brutus had some of his powers created with the OIHID limitaion.
So I said "Hold on a sec, you can't do that."
"Yes I can" he said.
"No you can't!!! You've already created the hero and his alter ego using multiform!"
"So?"
"Look, you've already defined the character as having 2 distinct forms. You've put limits on the Multiform power as to how and when the character can transform. You can't use OIHID to further limit the character in this case"
"Yes I can! It says so in the book! If the character has two distinct forms then he has the OIHID limitation"
"The character Brutus is never going to be limited by an OIHID limitaion!! He will always be either Brutus at full strength or Virgil the normal weakling. There will never be a scenario where Brutus can't access his powers due to an OIHID limitaion while in Brutus mode!"
"Yes he will!!! He can only access those powers while he's in Brutus mode! THerefore he can apply OIHID!!"
We argued like that for quite some time. Ultimately - I'm the GM - I told him he could either use the multiform option or the OIHID option. NOT BOTH
He was miffed at me for a while but he got over it.
Am I in the right here?? Am I correct in my interpretation of the rules?? Or am I just crazy??