Re: Fantasy Hero 6E - initial impressions
Just an impression, not a complete read through.
What I liked:
Hardcover*
Size of the book (480pgs)
Full Color
Glossy Pages
Layout and Graphic Design
Artwork
Illustrative Quotes*
Handy Tables
Bibliography
Index
What I did not like:
*Like the hardcover but am concerned about appearance of adhesive binding instead of stitched, but if there is not future problem with pages falling out with healthy use of the book then it is a non-issue.
*Like the illustrative quotes, but they were much overused in my opinion, anywhere from 1 to 7 quotes on every page (from what I can tell by paging through) in the first 2 chapters alone, chapter 3 is a little better, then it starts to reach an acceptable level in chapter 4, even better in chapter 5, but they are still used the rest of the way.
The following wall of text will seem somewhat stressed to the extreme, but that is using the extreme as a tool to illustrate a point that the illustrative quoting was used in an extreme. I only use it in hopes that the next products will be treated with a bit more moderation in the illustrative quoting area, not to bash the entire work of Fantasy Hero 6E.
I understand that the first couple chapters are about getting into the fantasy genre, but with the bibliography in the back, which is very appreciated, the quotes could have been reduced by half easily and plenty of additional Fantasy Hero material that would have direct application could utilize that space instead, like a more extensive magic college / spell list as one possible example. Even with a possible grimoire or two coming out later, I would liked to have seen more spells per college and more colleges listed in this book and this could have been accomplished by eliminating half or more of the quotes throughout the book.
I see this is a popular dislike and the post about the greatest compliment received at GenCon about Fantasy Hero was the illustrative quotes strikes me as being somewhat odd because that is merely copying others' works. I would think the greatest compliment would have been about the author's work.
"I got just about the best compliment I could imagine when someone told me that all the illustrative quotes convinced him there was a lot of good Fantasy reading out there he’d missed, and that he intended to correct that."
The thing I like about them is that it helps stir the imagination, but that was overkill. I wasn't intent on buying a book for quotes, I was intent on buying Fantasy Hero. The bibliography with some quotes here and there, along with the italicized titles of additional sources in some paragraphs would have been plenty to show me there are more fantasy sources I need to be gleaning from.
However, the source I wanted to glean from the most was Fantasy Hero itself.
Overall the book is aesthetically appealing, looks meaty and invites me to read it over and over again. I really like that.