Re: Western Hero Book
Kinda. Lots of other demony goodness and player characters can have some strange stuff too. "Hucksters" that use magic, "Mad Scientists" that use strange inventions, Indian Shamans, etc.
I always wanted to make a Gunfighter/Priest that uses a holy pistola (ala Supernatural), exorcism and the good book to lay the smack down on the unholy scourge. Played by Clint Eastwood of course.
Though I don't own any of the books, after flipping through them at the FLGS, I just never quite shined to the system much but loved the setting and thought HERO could do a good job of it.
I just mentioned it since you could always sell it to your one player as "Supernatural" meets Wild, Wild West so it's not really a "western", your other player could make a character with a special ability/supernatural power that sets him apart from everyone else and you get to run the western game you want.