Re: Heroes for pay
I agree with Clonus: paid heroes are less heroic in absolute terms because the heroes have an ulterior, and selfish, motive to their actions. This doesn’t make them unheroic, just less heroic, again just as Clonus said.
That said, a “Heroes for Hire” campaign presents a lot of very interesting ideas. Here’s ten story hooks or twists for a heroes for hire campaign:
1.) While on a mission for their employer, perhaps chasing their escaping target, the heroes see a more severe crime in progress. Do they let their quarry go to save the day, completed their hired tasks, or try to do both?
2.) The heroes’ employer has sent them on a mission that puts them in conflict with other heroes hired by another organization. Assuming the heroes talk it out, they realize that both employers seem to have legitimate reason for hiring the heroes. How do the PCs handle this?
3.) During a slow time, the heroes are offered a opportunity to compete in some sort of superpowered athletic or pugilistic competition for broadcast TV. Is this an ethical use of their superpowers?
4.) Citizen groups picket the PCs because the citizens feel the heroes are ignoring the needs of the poor in favor of those who can pay for the services of the superheroes. Or the policemen’s union pickets them for infringement on the role of the police.
5.) Via proxy, a villain hires the heroes to:
a. Fight another villain (or other heroes through some subterfuge) for the employer’s gain.
b. Go on a shaggy dog mission so they villain can run amok
c. Perform some work that turns out to be unpopular so that public opinion turns against the heroes.
6.) After a successful mission, an employer cannot or will not pay the heroes. What action can they take?
7.) The heroes’ national government decides to nationalize the Heroes for Hire industry. The PCs’ private organization will be subsumed within the greater governmental organization, and the heroes may be used for less than heroic purposes.
8.) Where do you buy insurance for your Hire A Hero business? An interesting downtime session can be built around obtaining the necessary insurance, representation, permits, and the like for running a heroic business. Having the players create a logo and business card can be an interesting teambuilding exercise.
9.) Heroes, maybe the PCs or maybe another NPC hero for hire group, feel that their compensation is inappropriately low. What action do they take? Do they organize into a labor union? How do they respond to claims that they are greedy money grabbers in the media?
10.) Through running a successful hire a hero business, the heroes have earned substantial wealth and fame. How do they explain this in their secret identities? What sort of problems does fame and wealth create for those with public identities?