Re: Reimagining the Superhero
One that's well written? Something that doesn't cycle through the same four plots over and over and over, and that has characters that behave like human beings?
Forgive my cranky old man routine, but every time I look in on the output of DC and Marvel I'm amazed at how bad it is. I'm afraid to reread the comic books I liked when I was a kid. I expect it'll turn out that they were crap too.
On a more positive note, I can think of some books that successfully "reimagined" the superhero. Grant Morrison's runs on Animal Man and Doom Patrol were kind of brilliant. (How weird is it that he now writes the latest reality reboot for DC?) Planetary was great. What I've seen of Powers and Ex Machina were promising. Ex Machina is particularly interesting - it's about a guy who uses his fame as a superhero to launch a career in politics. It's sort of like a downscaled West Wing, except that there's some weird stuff going on in the background. The Boys has potential. The first few Wild Cards books were good.
I'd love to hear more recommendations.
For me, the urban fantasy genre has picked up where superheroes left off. I get fantastical tales in a contemporary setting, but better plots and more compelling characters. Sure, I have plenty of nostalgia for the X-Men and Teen Titans and so on...but I'm much more likely to pick up the latest Dresden Files novel, or rewatch an episode of Buffy, than seek out a comic book nowadays.
But superheroes clearly still have a hold on my imagination, or I wouldn't be here. I'm even in a superhero game. But the fun of it for me is in exploring my character's psychology and trying to artfully chronicle his moral decay, not beating up Captain Destructo. I would love to play in a Planetary-style game. Or something more in the horror/occult department, or Warehouse 13 with superpowers.