Re: The Big Arguments
Killershrike is correct in his view of the design intent for Shape Shift. I've emailed Steve Long when the 5th Edition came out asking for some clarification on the intent of Shape Shift. If you email him directly, I'm sure you'll find that Killershrike is correct on how the power is supposed to work.
Killershrike, your posts do come across as condescending, although I'm sure that was not your intent. Not sure what advise I could give you to help you keep that from happening.
Phil, to try to help clarify how Shape Shift was intended to work I'll use a concrete example.
You could use Shape Shift to Look, Feel, Sound, Taste, Smell, and for all intents "Appear" to be a wooden chair.
Anyone who saw you would see a wooden chair.
They could tap your legs and they would sound like and feel like wood.
The could smell the wood smell that you would have.
However, they could not sit in the chair like a normal wooden chair. Why?
Because you are not a chair. Your body is not made of actual wood, you don't have the density, nor the tensile strength of wood. The configuration of your flesh and blood body has changed to match the volume shape of the chair. The surface of you body has changed to appear to be same as a wooden chair, but inside you're still the same flesh and blood person you started out as.
Someone sitting on you would know that they were not sitting in a wooden chair, even if you were strong enough to hold them. Why?
Because you don't act like a wooden chair that's being sat on.
That's not to say they would know that the wooden chair was a Shape Shifter, but simply that there's something wrong with the wooden chair.
Not sure if this helps you understand what Steve Long had in mind, but the power does work the way it was intended.
Just My Humble Opinion
- Christopher Mullins