Jump to content

DoctorImpossible

HERO Member
  • Posts

    80
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    6

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from aylwin13 in I need a name for my supervillain mafia   
    "The Community"
    Never intended to become a name, just like the classic name for the Mafia: "La Cosa Nostra" is literally just the phrase "our thing", used to refer obscurely to the crime organisation you're running. In the case of "The Community", it was a case of people involved always providing themselves with plausible deniability and even a veneer of respectability, as they do things on behalf of "The Community".
     
    They don't expect you to pay for protection or anything. They simply prefer you to be a generous donor, providing the community with "necessary funding". They don't try to recruit impressionable young mutants or metahumans, to serve as lieutenants of a street gang. No, they simply welcome them to the super-powered community. And if it ends up with them implicated for, or even involved in, some initial crimes, that's just more evidence that the rest of the world is out to get people like us, and only people in The Community really have your back. The super-"heroes"? They're all just sell-outs.
  2. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to death tribble in I need a name for my supervillain mafia   
    Something innocuous
     
    The Business
    The Organisation
  3. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Healing as a super power   
    Having the physical capacity of a healing super-power doesn't mean that they have the psychological inclination towards, or a desire for, a position in a hospital or any of the other IRL "healer" jobs. 
     
    On the other hand, having no super-power that seems very combative or whatever is no impediment at all to many, many people who have gone on to be nonpowered but still a super-hero or super-villain. You are actually already a step up the power list, as a person who *does* have super-powers.
  4. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Opal in Mutants: Why does this idea work?   
    That bit says it all, really. 
     
    Not objective, but debateable.
  5. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Opal in Mutants: Why does this idea work?   
    So I did some quickie research, since I'd been away from Marvel for many years, and, well, another thing pops up, for me.
     
    While mutants are subjected to discrimination in the Marvel universe, turning out to be a mutant, in addition to possible cool (or icky, or overwhelming) powers, is also an instant membership in an exclusive club.   Defining an out-group creates another in-group of it's own, and it's part of the Mutant X-whatever franchise's appeal, identifying with your heroes in that group.
     
    But, it's also problematic, because it gives the victims and the oppressors *both* an incentive to keep the artificial divide going - and it makes being an 'ally' problematic, too - normal humans don't go joining the X-Men just to show solidarity and help out, presumably, not because there aren't a few humans out there who'd be more than willing to, but because Xavier &c don't ever even think of recruiting them, because they're not mutants.  It's equally problematic IRL, so the analogy continues....
  6. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to steriaca in Mutants: Why does this idea work?   
    I do believe there are a few Mutates as members of the X-Men over the years.  So it is possible for those who have powers but got them artificially to join the club.
     
    They are:
     
    Mimic: Ok, Mimic blackmailed his way on to the team, and didn't last long. But he wasn't a mutant.
     
    Juggernaut: Well, he is Professor X's step brother. His powers come from a magical gem created by a demon/god.
     
    Deadpool: People forget that his powers are artificially induced by Frances.
     
    Ok...not a lot, but we got three of them. Go figure. 
     
    Also, could Mimic copy the 'human Shroger's cat' property of Forget-Me-Not?
  7. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Opal in Mutants: Why does this idea work?   
    It wouldn't be a very good metaphor if it did, because racism doesn't make sense on its own terms.  
     
    And, if I'm following you, that's your point: that Marvel Mutant Hysteria makes too much sense, and is too reasonable? 
     
    Even though, for instance, the rationalization that they're a threat breaks down since - as was one of the first things pointed out in this thread - mutates, aliens, sorcerers, and super-tech geniuses are every bit as dangerous, but can somehow be trusted with their earth-shattering powers (or, at least, judged for how they use them) because they're not mutants?
  8. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Opal in Mutants: Why does this idea work?   
    I haven't been reading Marvel comics for some decades, so correct me if I'm wrong, but Marvel Mutants can be born to typical human couples, and "humans" and "mutants" can mate and produce fertile offspring (scientific definition of the same species)?
     
    Bigots /can/ & do point to contemporary genetic testing for relative occurrence of various markers to show genetic differences, and they can point to all sorts of statistics that 'prove' meaningful differences between themselves and the objects of their ire (who, in turn, can point to the same statistics as proof of oppression). 
     
    Ultimately, it comes down to what you choose to believe.  If you want to arbitrarily define a group as Other and persecute them, you can, and you can come up with 'real' reasons to rationalize what you're doing, people who want to join you will find those reasons real (regardless) and compelling (though it's the group cohesion gained from Othering the out-group that's compelling), and those who want to oppose you can poke holes in them and hopefully persuade most more rational people not to join you.  
     
    Maybe the willing suspension of disbelief traditional in the genre is problematic for that metaphor, since it's easy for the reader to accept "mutants are different because some of them have powers and some look different and all ping a 'mutant detector,'" as part of the willing suspension of disbelief that allows for superpowers &c in the first place.  Or, maybe it's just that much more powerful, because it lets you - hopefully very uncomfortably - into the mind of the bigot who /really believes/ in the differences among the arbitrary races (or whatever) he choses to believe in, all evidence to the contrary subject to rationalization and confirmation bias.   OTOH, I couldn't quickly find any confirmation that Marvel canon says Mutants aren't human and are destined to supplant humanity - seems some mutants on Magneto's side of the fence believe that, and some humans fear it, is all.  OTOOH, I could find virtually nothing about non-powered mutants, which makes me wonder what the X-gene is supposed to be or how it's supposed to work in the Medelian sense, at all....?
     
     
     
     
  9. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Opal in Mutants: Why does this idea work?   
    There's a story like that about RL racism, too:  Tom Driscoll in Mark Twain's Puddn’head Wilson.
     
    Like Marvel's mutant-hating metaphor, racism doesn't actually make sense or hold together logically, because the arbitrary definitions of race can oblige the committed racist to flip-flop from embracing an individual as a brother to hating him (or vice versa) with proof of pedigree - like the a wave of the metaphorical mutant-detector.
     
    (ps: I hope I'm not appearing too strident on this topic.)
     
  10. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Opal in Mutants: Why does this idea work?   
    So, yes, OT1H, all the reasoning around mutant hysteria does fall down upon examination, but then as a metaphor for racism, that works, because the rationalizations an constructs of racism, and race itself, also don't hold up to dispassionate scrutiny.
     
    OTOH, the consistent presentation of a group as dangerous is just part of prejudice against that group.  Maybe Marvel should have introduced a lot more non-/trivially- powered but obvious mutants as 'extras' in background scenes and as victims of mutant hysteria, to make that point more clearly?
     
    Personally, that still feels on-point for me as a metaphor of the crazy ways race can work.  In past times and places, there were racists who were absolutely certain they could tell a Jew or an Irishman or whatever at a glance, while today, we don't see it, like, at all.  
     
    Certainly, tho, a story or two of a mutant spreading around a mutate or mystic origin story as a way of "Passing" might've been a nice idea.
     
    OK, well, I can agree to disagree on that point.  I quite like allegory as a literary technique.  It allows the reader to look at the logical structure and moral/ethical implications of a real-world phenomenon without all the unexamined emotional attachment they may have to it.  Sure, some of us can be super-dispassionate without any such crutch, but even if all of us could, it can still be an aesthetically pleasing literary device.
  11. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Tjack in Funny Powers & Modifiers   
    Dr. Terrance (Terry) Thirteen.  I think he was a recurring character in either House of Mystery or House of Secrets.  Both were horror books that featured stand-alone stories.  He was kind of a more grown up version of Scooby-Doo.
  12. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Good Pulp Movies to watch   
    I don't think the specific era is important to whether it is or is not pulp. It being pulp is more about the action adventure, the fact that the heroes never even question their own decision to do the right thing, even when it gets them into danger, the wide exploration of the setting, and so on. 
  13. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Funny Powers & Modifiers   
    Immunity to (Insert Genre You Don't Like)
     
    Not sure it would be accepted in a tabletop game. Or rather, instead of actually building it into the sheet, I suspect most people are going to prefer it if you just ask ahead of a campaign that it not feature X, Y, or Z. If it was built in Hero, it would be basically a very powerful version of Transform as an area around you, big enough to cover any part of the setting you can be percieving. 
     
    But, funnily enough, it does exist in DC. There is, or *was* at least, a paranormal investigator who looked into all sorts of the supernatural goings on, amd always was able to debunk them and shame the con artists behind it. In his original stories that was because his universe was a normal one. But, as the DC universe became more connected, and he was gradually sharing a world with *actual* Greek Gods and ghosts and ghouls, it was retconned into him being a metahuman who was reality warping, so the things he investigated really were real all along... until he was in range of them, at which point they turned into normal human con artistry, with all the signs of having existed as that the whole time, only to flip back to being supernatural once he'd left.
     
    Personally, I'd like to try using it to make sure the campaign world was always some light-hearted family friendly adventure, not a grim, dark iron age game, or anything.
     
  14. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from Steve in Funny Powers & Modifiers   
    Immunity to (Insert Genre You Don't Like)
     
    Not sure it would be accepted in a tabletop game. Or rather, instead of actually building it into the sheet, I suspect most people are going to prefer it if you just ask ahead of a campaign that it not feature X, Y, or Z. If it was built in Hero, it would be basically a very powerful version of Transform as an area around you, big enough to cover any part of the setting you can be percieving. 
     
    But, funnily enough, it does exist in DC. There is, or *was* at least, a paranormal investigator who looked into all sorts of the supernatural goings on, amd always was able to debunk them and shame the con artists behind it. In his original stories that was because his universe was a normal one. But, as the DC universe became more connected, and he was gradually sharing a world with *actual* Greek Gods and ghosts and ghouls, it was retconned into him being a metahuman who was reality warping, so the things he investigated really were real all along... until he was in range of them, at which point they turned into normal human con artistry, with all the signs of having existed as that the whole time, only to flip back to being supernatural once he'd left.
     
    Personally, I'd like to try using it to make sure the campaign world was always some light-hearted family friendly adventure, not a grim, dark iron age game, or anything.
     
  15. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Creating or fixing roads   
    I think Transform is already effectively a Cumulative power by default. The text of it describes using it again and again to make the change happen more.
  16. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Create a Villain Theme Team!   
    Alright...
    How about "The ThinkBank", a team of at least 5 wealthy genius types who, bored with their endless charity fundraisers and thinking that they could do a better job of saving the world if only they were running everything, devote their genius, and cash, toward attempting the thrilling business of total global domination together?
  17. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Create a Villain Theme Team!   
    Hungry 
    Hungry has legally changed her name to the single word, in a genuine tribute to the single word adjective monikers of Disney's seven dwarves.  
     
    From her father, a wealthy crimelord, she has inherited a great deal of wealth, and also dwarfism. From her mother, she inherited a genius level of intelligence, a talent for engineering, and an unceasing hedonistic gluttony.
     
    She has given up on walking anymore, as she prefers being "carried around like a Queen from times of yore", aboard a seat within the two metre tall war-robot that she pilots. 
  18. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Terrible Writing Advice: Rebels   
    .
  19. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in What can tempt the person who has everything?   
    The villain, provided that they have already proven somewhat capable as villains in the past, could simply offer that they will turn a new leaf and be super-heroes rather than super-villains in the future, if this scheme goes well. Or even just that they'll retire.
  20. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Send out your potions!   
    Potion of Slippery Ness - Grants you a few of the more desirable qualities of famous adventurer, Slippery Ness. Makes you a bit tougher, gives you some regeneration, add a bit of a strong will, and other such things.
  21. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from CaptainCoulson in Real People Who Would have Been Supers In A Supers Universe   
    Honestly, I'm starting to wonder about some people becoming super, not because of their own efforts, strictly speaking, but because they're the sort of people that an enterprising super-scientist/magic-user is likely to decide might make for a good hero and therefore they end up gifted with some advancedbtechnology or mystical artefacts or super-soldier serum or some arcane empowerment. 
     
    Like, we'd end up with Dwayne Johnson and Keanu Reeves showing up to join the world-saving superhero team, festooned with magical artefacts and wearing power armour, but even if you took all the gadgets and magic items away, they still turn out to be full of healing factors and superstrength and casting spells. All on the basis that the two of them have a reputation as really nice people, who are very physically capable.
  22. Like
    DoctorImpossible reacted to eepjr24 in Creating or fixing roads   
    I ended up going with Transform. It's much easier to figure the math using area of effect, I didn't have to play with Opaque or Configurable (for rougher terrain), and I don't have to worry about people arguing whether they could turn it sideways and use it as defenses. There is another spell for that already. 😃
     
    I will likely design another one with Tunneling for use in creating tunnels, still have to figure some things as I don't want matter to be destroyed as part of the process.
     
    - E
  23. Thanks
    DoctorImpossible reacted to Ninja-Bear in Creating or fixing roads   
    I say go with Transformation-minor. Minor because good roads (or more precisely bad roads) affect your horses your your wagons and travel time. Now if they can also do the inverse- good road to bad, to answer @Spence’s question as to why the write up, I can see a scenario where the Earth mage casting the inverse so as to slow up pursuers. Of course depending on casting time and how close the pursers are.
  24. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from DeleteThisAccount in Terrible Writing Advice: Rebels   
    .
  25. Like
    DoctorImpossible got a reaction from DeleteThisAccount in Create a Villain Theme Team!   
    Alright...
    How about "The ThinkBank", a team of at least 5 wealthy genius types who, bored with their endless charity fundraisers and thinking that they could do a better job of saving the world if only they were running everything, devote their genius, and cash, toward attempting the thrilling business of total global domination together?
×
×
  • Create New...