-
Posts
64,407 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
33
Reputation Activity
-
L. Marcus reacted to DShomshak in Political Discussion Thread (With Rules)
Clearly, some people are operating on very different narratives. I like to look at it this way: Is illegal immigration a home invasion or a parking violation?
Both are violations of law, but most people would say they are of greatly different severity. When people park where they shouldn't, we charge them a fine but we don't revoke their license, confiscate their car and demand massive government expenditure to make sure nobody double-parks or parks in a fire zone again. Neither do we shrug and say that since we can't stop everyone from parking in the wrong place every time, we should just give up and abandon all parking regulations.
To me, that describes illegal immigration. People haven't followed the rules, but it's no big deal. Levy a penalty, but give them a chance to re-park somewhere else.
A report on All Things Considered claimed that more than half the "illegals" actually entered the country legally but overstayed their visas. So this is nothing more than letting the parking meter run out on your car. Pay your ticket, move on.
But clearly, to many people illegal immigration is more home invasion. Strangers have violently entered a place that is theirs to rob them and do them harm.
The problem I see with this emotional response is that the country is not your home. Your home is yours. Your country is not. You, individually, do not get to say who belongs and who doesn't. Moreover, you are not, personally, robbed or harmed by the mere act of someone crossing a border without permission. Any harm is likely diffuse and indirect.
No matter how intense and visceral the sense of violation, feelings are not facts. Public policy should be carefully considered and made on the most objective grounds possible. Not just because some people are confused about personal boundaries.
(Though the point about employers of the undocumented is another issue. Here, I think the harm is quite objective and measurable -- including to the undocumented.)
Dean Shomshak
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from tkdguy in More space news!
... I have a vision of elder species playing Why Are You Hitting Yourself with newcomers.
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from Pariah in Complicate the Person Above
Pariah is one of the preeminent ice sculpture artists working today, specializing in bespoke snowflakes.
-
-
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from Pariah in The "Nice Happy" Thread
Turns out, I'm healthier than I thought.
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from Old Man in The "Nice Happy" Thread
Had a coronary angiography yesterday. Not really tip-top, but definitely an A grade.
Hurt like a motherbitch when they pullet out the introducer, though. Vascular spasm.
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from Bazza in The "Nice Happy" Thread
Had a coronary angiography yesterday. Not really tip-top, but definitely an A grade.
Hurt like a motherbitch when they pullet out the introducer, though. Vascular spasm.
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from Pariah in Longest Running Thread EVER
You will know if it has happened by someone acing the test.
-
L. Marcus reacted to Pariah in Longest Running Thread EVER
Yes. It's called "Non-Gaming Discussion".
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from Pariah in Longest Running Thread EVER
I don't even touch alcohol. I have a sneaking suspicion that I would be a really mean drunk.
-
L. Marcus reacted to Pariah in NGD Scenes from a Hat
The Computer keeps telling you to go outside, because sitting in your room all day is treason.
New Topic: Fun things to do in Des Moines, Iowa.
-
-
L. Marcus reacted to Cancer in Musings on Random Musings
No ... I wanted to catch the 3:30 bus, and good form snark takes more time than I had.
-
-
L. Marcus got a reaction from Pariah in Musings on Random Musings
I had good ones. Were they helpful?
-
L. Marcus reacted to Cygnia in And now, for your daily dose of cute...
"So, human, what were you planning on having?"
-
L. Marcus reacted to Xavier Onassiss in Political Discussion Thread (With Rules)
Trump never gets tired of reminding us all how superior he is. Mainly because he isn't.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-