Re: LOTR thoughts
I don't want to give up all the details of my setting, but the Sons of Denethor were the creation of a more insidious Evil. The majority of it came from various places on the net, but the SoD were from Tolkien himself. In that next novel he started children of Gondor were actually acting like orcs and popularizing the evils of the Third Age. Where JRRT left off, I took up the mantle.
There was also talk of Sauron's daughter.
In my campaign, the subjugated of Nurn were happy to be out from under the yoke of Sauron, but old hatreds die hard. I played a lot with all of that, but as the most versed in the lore, the players just took it for what it was as there wasn't a whole lot left of Tolkien's Middle Earth but the locations and the 'history'. I can see Andy's side of enjoying TA more because of that.