Re: +1 DC only with Haymaker
All true, and as far as those types of CSL are concerned, I agree with you. It becomes an issue when the character has Rapid attack with the HTH only limitation, or Weapon Master defined to work with All Hand-to-Hand Killing Attacks, etc. -- then they want to apply it to a Ranged HKA.
I haven't even seen this kind of pretzel logic used in other game systems, because HERO is the only system I know of that builds thrown weapons this way. In any other game system, (or in "real life" for that matter) a thrown weapon is a ranged attack by definition, and nobody with half a brain would argue otherwise.
Edited to add: Not that I'm "bashing" HERO. It's flexible enough to avoid this issue by building thrown weapons as STR-based ranged attacks instead of "ranged hand weapons", which works just as well for my purposes.