Re: Tuala Morn Errata?
Thanks, but I'm not sure I want to interrupt the writing of 6E for this - it's more like a little strange thing that would best be addressed in a broader list of errors. And frankly, I'm not even sure that I've got it right. Maybe the boards could check my reasoning?
Basically, I think the limitation values for beneficial geasa on page 136 are backwards - a greater limitation value is given for a restriction that is actually less restrictive to the character. The beneficial geasa ("can only be killed by X") are written up as damage reduction, only versus deathblows, only against limited type of attack, with "limited type of attack" being "everything except X."
So "can only be killed by spears" is DR, only versus deathblows, ineffective against spears (-1/2). And "can only be killed as the result of some incredible combination of factors" is DR, only versus deathblows ineffective almost never (-2). The first writeup is therefore cheaper than the second, whereas the second is a more powerful, less limited power.
Sanity check?