Jump to content

Grailknight

HERO Member
  • Posts

    2,768
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from C.R.Ryan in 6th Edition Vehicle Books   
    No, there is no dedicated vehicle book. I think that between the 5th edition book, The Ultimate Base and Star Hero you could find all the relevant rules and see what changes need to be made from 5th to 6th edition.
  2. Like
    Grailknight reacted to unclevlad in Weight Damage   
    Not even sure I buy that.  Page cite please?  The objects as weapons section doesn't appear to support this.  It actually goes the other way.  If I can pick up a particularly solid object...say, 1 inch thick solid steel rod stock...with my casual STR, then I get full STR, plus probably a few more for using such a durable object.
     
    And it's nonsensical to say you can throw it for more damage than you can get by using it as a club.  
     
  3. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Old Man in What Have You Watched Recently?   
    Just returned from Mobile Suit Gundam Seed: Freedom which is only playing today and tomorrow in the US.
     
    This movie is more a love letter to series fans than many theatrical releases. If you aren't an anime fan you can skip this but if you are it's a visual treat and if you're a Gundam Seed fan you should see this. It its most of the highs and skips many of the lows of Seed and Seed Destiny.
     
    The bad: The villains are brand new to the series but have been supposedly ruling their little kingdom quietly off the world stage for decades. Of course, during this time they've developed bleeding edge technology ahead of even the world powers and a fanatical and genocidal political agenda.
     
     
    The good: Everyone is and back and in character.
                      The art and sound are on point. They do have some CGI battles mixed in, but they don't distract or detract.
                      No more magic trick survival escapes. You can see how everyone escapes their potential deaths, and none require miraculous luck.
                      Lacus gets a mech! And a rather risqué spacesuit.
                      All the ships sail and reach port!
     
    For the general anime fan this is about a 6.5 for those like me, who are SEED fans this is an 8.5.
     
     
     
                     
     
     
     
                   
     
  4. Haha
  5. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Starlord in NBA 2023-2024   
    The "Superteams" era was always a thing. Miami just marked the first time that it was done by player agency.
     
    Before it took smart management and some luck to assemble the necessary talent to win a championship. It's since been popular for the top players to use free agency to group with their friends. But it's always taken at least one Hall of Fame talent and several All-Stars to win a title. The two seeming exceptions were just a case of the supporting cast being older, Milwaukee with Lopez, Holliday and Middleton supporting Giannis or younger unknowns in Toronto with Siakam, Anunoby and Van Vleet supporting Kawaii. Teamwork is great but you've got to have the talent.
  6. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from unclevlad in NBA 2023-2024   
    The "Superteams" era was always a thing. Miami just marked the first time that it was done by player agency.
     
    Before it took smart management and some luck to assemble the necessary talent to win a championship. It's since been popular for the top players to use free agency to group with their friends. But it's always taken at least one Hall of Fame talent and several All-Stars to win a title. The two seeming exceptions were just a case of the supporting cast being older, Milwaukee with Lopez, Holliday and Middleton supporting Giannis or younger unknowns in Toronto with Siakam, Anunoby and Van Vleet supporting Kawaii. Teamwork is great but you've got to have the talent.
  7. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Pariah in NBA 2023-2024   
    The "Superteams" era was always a thing. Miami just marked the first time that it was done by player agency.
     
    Before it took smart management and some luck to assemble the necessary talent to win a championship. It's since been popular for the top players to use free agency to group with their friends. But it's always taken at least one Hall of Fame talent and several All-Stars to win a title. The two seeming exceptions were just a case of the supporting cast being older, Milwaukee with Lopez, Holliday and Middleton supporting Giannis or younger unknowns in Toronto with Siakam, Anunoby and Van Vleet supporting Kawaii. Teamwork is great but you've got to have the talent.
  8. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from MrAgdesh in Skirmish gaming   
    Hero IS a skirmish miniature combat game.  That's superhero combat in a nutshell. It just happens to also have a unique character creation detailing system and a good, if dry, skill system.
  9. Like
    Grailknight reacted to unclevlad in Weight Damage   
    Why does that exhaust the space?  Third option:  add the 2 damage aspects.  IOW, if it takes 2d6 to lift, then the total damage is VELO + 2 DCs, up to the max of PD + BODY (per the throwing damage rules).  Your options basically say that the object's mass becomes irrelevant once the velo damage passes the STR to lift...which is generally a trivial amount.  
     
    Combining the two is much more in line with throwing damage.  If I have a 40 STR and throw a 50 pound anvil, it does 8d6...because that's the net force involved, between the mass of the anvil and its velocity.  Here, the velo is independent...the "throwing STR" is the gravitational pull of the Earth, which is practically infinite...it's limited basically only by terminal velocity.  It just takes a while to reach it, too.  The velo is the 'excess STR' over and above what's needed to lift it....think about flipping the situation.  A 40 STR character throws a 50 kg cannonball straight up.  How high does it go?  We need its initial velocity.  50 kg requires 5 STR, so there's 7d6 from the velocity.  OK, that means the starting velocity would be 14m...bingo!  
     
    And honestly, note that the rule is still ridiculously lax.  Because a 50 kg mass only adds 1d6????  That's lame.
     
     
    Mmm...based on what?  I think there's multiple sections, and I'm suspecting they lead to different answers.  For example, in the Throwing...if we drop it down a bit to a 50 ton tank, something a 90 STR character *can* throw...the throwing rules say the full damage applies.
     
    The suggestions WRT heavy mass also say, the apply the damage based on the weight.
     
    Basically, the 90 STR can't add more damage from his STR, when he smacks you with the destroyer...but that doesn't mean it does 0 damage.
     
    Note that this is also consistent with the Heroic rules for weapons with STR mins.  You can only add damage based on your STR in excess of what's needed to wield the weapon.
  10. Sad
  11. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from LoneWolf in Pain without damage   
    So, in all these cases the pain is merely an SFX.
     
    But this is HERO, the mechanic can have any SFX that can be reasonably applied. What we really need to do is determine, on a case-by-case basis, what the actual mechanic we are trying to achieve is. I don't think this can be narrowed down to one method.
  12. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Old Man in What Have You Watched Recently?   
    They do start the jihad directly after this. The navigators have no choice but to allow it because spice is necessary for their abilities and because the navigators' limited prescience has shown that any attempt to seize the planet directly ends in an extinction level war on Arrakis which destroys spice production forever. 
  13. Haha
    Grailknight reacted to Starlord in The Advice Column   
    Sometimes you have to hug the people you hate to know how big to dig the hole in the backyard.
  14. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Steve in Child Collector   
    Even simpler, an Entangle as a Damage Shield that only works when used as an attack. You can add Cumulative to it to reflect the idea that it seems to be harder to escape after the initial entanglement.
  15. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Christopher R Taylor in Child Collector   
    Even simpler, an Entangle as a Damage Shield that only works when used as an attack. You can add Cumulative to it to reflect the idea that it seems to be harder to escape after the initial entanglement.
  16. Haha
    Grailknight got a reaction from Pariah in Political Discussion Thread (With Rules)   
    " I wouldn't believe him if his tongue were notarized"
     
    I am so stealing that for my next game.
  17. Haha
    Grailknight got a reaction from TrickstaPriest in Political Discussion Thread (With Rules)   
    " I wouldn't believe him if his tongue were notarized"
     
    I am so stealing that for my next game.
  18. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Lord Liaden in Political Discussion Thread (With Rules)   
    "The 2020 presidential election was rigged" is not spin. "The Biden family are criminals" is not spin. "COVID is a hoax" is not spin.
     
    People spreading demonstrable lies should be held accountable for the harm they do, which as we've seen, can be considerable.
  19. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Old Man in Political Discussion Thread (With Rules)   
    I've come to some grudging acceptance of the "hush money" label simply because large swaths of the electorate wouldn't pay attention at all if it were a "mere" election fraud trial.  I know my fellow Americans well enough to know that high treason isn't nearly as interesting as a porn star.
  20. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Lord Liaden in Grabbed Cape   
    This might be a good movie trope, but it doesn't translate well to HERO.
     
    You are essentially penalizing some SFX but how do you make consistent rulings? What exact length of hair triggers the penalty? Why wouldn't capes be like tear-away football jerseys? What about horns, tails or body spikes?
     
    If you use this on a PC, do they now get a Physical Limitation? You're imposing one as GM that the player did not present to you in character creation. How many of your NPC's will have that Limitation? Are you going to be constantly opposing anime girls or the Dora Milaje?
     
    If you really feel this should be in your game, then purchase some Limited Skill Levels with Grab that only apply vs targets with the given handholds. Then describe the results cinematically.
     
  21. Thanks
    Grailknight got a reaction from Steve in Grabbed Cape   
    This might be a good movie trope, but it doesn't translate well to HERO.
     
    You are essentially penalizing some SFX but how do you make consistent rulings? What exact length of hair triggers the penalty? Why wouldn't capes be like tear-away football jerseys? What about horns, tails or body spikes?
     
    If you use this on a PC, do they now get a Physical Limitation? You're imposing one as GM that the player did not present to you in character creation. How many of your NPC's will have that Limitation? Are you going to be constantly opposing anime girls or the Dora Milaje?
     
    If you really feel this should be in your game, then purchase some Limited Skill Levels with Grab that only apply vs targets with the given handholds. Then describe the results cinematically.
     
  22. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Christopher R Taylor in Grabbed Cape   
    I figure that kind of thing goes under special effect.  Grond does a grab maneuver, and gets something: On The Mighty Sampson, he grabs hair.  On Cape Girl he grabs cape.  If you really wanted to you could build the character with like a -1 DCV vs grab maneuvers (hero form only for Cape Girl).
  23. Thanks
    Grailknight got a reaction from Steve in Balancing damage and defenses   
    If you're trying to figure out how long a combat will be, then you need to factor in at least 2 other parameters. You need the SPD's of the participants and also relative OCV and DCV. with the other numbers you just gave 4-5 average SPD will be a 3-4 turn slog at if you hit on 11 or less and 2- 3 turns at 6-7 SPD. Even at 8 SPD or higher, you're going in 2 turns. Turning up OCV slightly will shorten the combats slightly but shifting just to 10 or less will make these combats take forever. Some will be decided by who runs out of END.
     
    You need to set all your variables and test them out. Only with a good baseline can you tweak.
     
  24. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Hugh Neilson in Balancing damage and defenses   
    This falls into the same category as many other limitations - is it limiting in the context of the specific character in the specific campaign? 
     
    The pricing question is an issue.  Typically, "resistant" has been a +1/2 advantage.  It doesn't seem like this has been re-evaluated with the evolution of killing attacks.  It was +1/2 when nonresistant defenses did not reduce Stun damage from killing attacks, which made nonresistant defenses considerably less valuable.

    If anything, the loss of reducing Drains and STUN damage from KAs suggests that nonresistant is more limiting for DN and DR than for normal defenses (ie moving Resistant Protection to PD and ED). It seems like either nonresistant DN and DR should still reduce STUN from KAs (and perhaps all switches between Resistant and Nonresistant should be repriced at -1/4) or nonresistant DN and DR should be a greater limitation than nonresistant defenses.
     
    The -1/2 for "only BOD" or "only STUN" presupposes that reducing each is of equal importance.  Where that supposition is not accurate for the specific campaign or character, I would take issue with the limitation.  In other words, as a GM, if you apply, and I allow, "No BOD" to your Negation or Reduction, then the onus is on me as GM to ensure that the limitation becomes relevant in actual gameplay.  For STUN Only, that means ensuring there are instances where you are at risk of BOD damage not reduced by these defenses. 
     
    If I have two players, one who pays full price for Negation (or Reduction) and one who takes a discount for "STUN only", the first player deserves to see some value for the extra points spent.
  25. Like
    Grailknight reacted to unclevlad in Balancing damage and defenses   
    I was doing 4 DCs of negation on those, versus 14 DEF.  3 DCs negation...do you treat that as 10 or 11 DEF?  It actually makes a pretty clear difference on something I use a lot...the risk of getting stunned.  Look at the percent chance of rolling a specific number in the mid-40s range on 12d6...it's about 6% per, so even that 1 point of difference is notable.  And that's just based on "round up or round down."  Going with 4 DCs vs. 14 DEF...no such issue.
     
    I see...ok, I'll fix the lead-in.  I re-wrote a LOT of the post and missed that I was using 3 DCs negation at the top.
×
×
  • Create New...