Jump to content

Grailknight

HERO Member
  • Posts

    2,749
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Reputation Activity

  1. Thanks
    Grailknight reacted to Pattern Ghost in Political Discussion Thread (With Rules)   
    If my premise were wrong, organizations (military, police, gangs) wouldn't have to train the reluctance to kill out of people. You'd be far harder pressed to find any credible stats indicating that "most people" are inclined to kill each other. The global murder rate (2019) is 6.2/100,000. So is 6.2 "most" or is 99,993.8 "most"?
     
  2. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Christopher R Taylor in Restricted power origins campaigns   
    Yes, this idea can work and work well. Giving everyone a common origin, makes it simpler to weave plots together. And it makes less work for the GM on organizations.  Plus, single can still be pretty broad in scope.
     
    It can also give some justification to fear by the population because these supers are different from the norm. All mages? They're after our souls! All cyborgs? They're going to turn us into spare parts! All mutants? We'll be replaced! Aliens? They'll enslave us and then eat us! It's much easier to fuel one strong conspiracy than lots of small ones.
  3. Sad
    Grailknight reacted to Cygnia in Extra! Extra! Read All About It!   
    The 2023 Hugo Awards: A Report on Censorship and Exclusion
  4. Thanks
    Grailknight reacted to Cancer in A.I is here and it will make the world worse.   
    Any number of places this could be posted here, but here's AI making an opportunity for all of us.
     

  5. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from DShomshak in Strange Crime: Sand Mafias   
    I had heard of this, but my idea of the problem was off by an order of magnitude. I had thought that the major issue was special grades of sand for computer chips. Knowing that it's for construction, make the problem much more serious. And it's insidiously mundane, who pays attention to sand trucks? And I can easily see a Bond movie based around this. They didn't really play up the water plot in Quantum of Solace.
  6. Like
    Grailknight reacted to DShomshak in Strange Crime: Sand Mafias   
    From the February 2024 issue of Scientific American: The world uses enormous quantities of sand, construction to silicon chips. This makes illegal sand mining one of the biggest rackets in the world, far exceeding other forms of illegal mining. Since this is Scientific American, much of the concern is about the resulting environmental damage -- but the big money in sand mining can corrupt governments at every level and fund other unsavory activities. Googling "sand mafia" turns up many other articles for further research.
     
    Illegal sand mining might be difficult to work into the usual urban vigilante Dark Champions game, but you might fit it into an international espionage game. Imagine a James Bond-style mastermind who uses sand mining to fund his terrorist scheme, coup plot or diabolical weapon. The death trap for captured agents should be obvious.
     
    https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/sand-mafias-are-plundering-the-earth/
     
    Dean Shomshak
  7. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from DentArthurDent in Looking at things differently   
    This gets back to something that we've discussed before, a unified standard for the Hero Universe.
     
    It would require all official Hero products to be examined and modified by a common editorial standard. There can and will be variation but there would need to be a consensus on levels of play like High and Low Fantasy, Heroic Adventuring (Westerns, Espionage, Black Ops, etc.), Beginning, Standard, High Power and Galactic Supers/ Magic campaigns and the spectrum of Martial Arts. And these editors would need real control over the ranges of what is allowed to be labelled as each.
     
    Not a change of the game per se but a change in editorial direction. You can still have Dr. Destroyer and the Geodesics in the same universe, but they would not appear in the same product.
  8. Thanks
    Grailknight got a reaction from Scott Ruggels in Wizards of the Coast Announces One D&D   
    Not so much Social Justice but Wokeness. As an example, inherently evil monster races have been pretty much removed from Pathfinder 2. Especially glaring was the goblins , who were despicable little rapists and torturers, were added as a PC race. You are supposed to believe that X years of lore was accomplished by "bad" goblins but any new PC's and NPC's were good acceptable citizens. 
  9. Thanks
    Grailknight reacted to LoneWolf in Use of Naked Advantage for Mental Powers to push through Opponent's Magic or Mental Defenses   
    Darkness does not require a way to turn it off.  UAA is what requires a reasonable way to turn it off.  So, the first instance would require some way to avoid the attack, but the second one does not.  The second instance does not have UAA it has Useable simultaneously by 16 people.  That means the targets have to be willing.  The price is also wrong for that one it should be + 1 ½ for 16 people.  The second instance has personal immunity, so I am assuming it was designed as a defense and does not affect the target. 
     
    It’s possible the power does have a reasonably common way to avoid it but is just not listed.  When I construct the power in Hero Designer it does not list the defense for the UAA, the comment section is commonly used for this, but nothing prompts you for it.
     
    The power is fairly strong but there are plenty of ways to get around it.  As Grailknight pointed out combat sense will negate this. 
  10. Like
    Grailknight reacted to LoneWolf in Use of Naked Advantage for Mental Powers to push through Opponent's Magic or Mental Defenses   
    You cannot have darkness that covers the unusual sense group as a whole.  Each unusual sense is considered a completely different sense group.  So, you can have darkness to detect souls (in the unusual sense group), but that does not block another sense in the unusual sense group. You would have to buy each unusual sense as a separate sense.  This does mean when you build your enhanced sense you don’t get any sense groups modifiers for free.  Just build a sense from the ground up to counter this darkness.  It will probably be fairly expensive and if you want to use it to attack you will need at least ranged and targeting and probably sense.  
     
    Naked Advantage will not even work. All a Naked Advantage does is allow you to buy an advantage or adder for a power or group of powers.  It does not allow you to create a power you could not create with the normal rules.  If you can build the power with naked advantage, you can build it without it.  
     
     
    Something like this would work.  Detect Souls (unusual) Discriminatory, Ranged, Sense, Targeting for 27 Points.
  11. Like
  12. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Doc Democracy in Looking at things differently   
    This gets back to something that we've discussed before, a unified standard for the Hero Universe.
     
    It would require all official Hero products to be examined and modified by a common editorial standard. There can and will be variation but there would need to be a consensus on levels of play like High and Low Fantasy, Heroic Adventuring (Westerns, Espionage, Black Ops, etc.), Beginning, Standard, High Power and Galactic Supers/ Magic campaigns and the spectrum of Martial Arts. And these editors would need real control over the ranges of what is allowed to be labelled as each.
     
    Not a change of the game per se but a change in editorial direction. You can still have Dr. Destroyer and the Geodesics in the same universe, but they would not appear in the same product.
  13. Haha
    Grailknight reacted to Starlord in The Advice Column   
  14. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Starlord in The Advice Column   
  15. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Christopher R Taylor in Stronghold Prison Populations   
    Reed housed the gate to the Negative Zone prison in the Baxter Building but he really, really should have known better.
  16. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from DentArthurDent in Variants on the Alien Cop Trope?   
    So have the two villains come to Earth in a loose alliance and let one of the NPC cops be after both of them. They could normally handle them individually but need help against both. or beef up one of the villains with the adventure's plot hook and have the detective and cyborg/spaceship be partners tracking them down.
  17. Haha
    Grailknight reacted to Starlord in Funny Pics II: The Revenge   
  18. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Jkeown in Variants on the Alien Cop Trope?   
    So have the two villains come to Earth in a loose alliance and let one of the NPC cops be after both of them. They could normally handle them individually but need help against both. or beef up one of the villains with the adventure's plot hook and have the detective and cyborg/spaceship be partners tracking them down.
  19. Like
    Grailknight reacted to unclevlad in General Sports Thread   
    Thing is, those criteria will apply very broadly...state or private, FBS or FCS...probably even Div II, where IIRC there's still some scholarships.
     
    Title IX only forces schools to cut both mens' and womens' non-revenue sports.  For example, at UNM, there's both men's and women's golf, cross country, tennis, and track and field;  there's baseball and softball as well, that are effectively equivalent for this purpose.
     
    It's not a Pandora moment yet, as there are still appeals to be made.  That said, if the appeals fail as I think they will...I go back to the criteria cited.  They're fundamental, basic definitions of "what is employment?"  On those grounds, it's totally a Pandora moment.
     
    Side thought?  I wouldn't be surprised that the Big 10 and SEC expected this, and this is part of the whole "WE are gonna start making rules because the NCAA is inept" announcement.
  20. Thanks
    Grailknight reacted to Lord Liaden in Who is the MOST Annoying Villain you have Encountered?   
    Duke Bushido answered this point in general above with great eloquence, so I've nothing to add there. I will just point out that the issue with CLOWN is not that a bad GM would use them for the purpose of pissing off the players. It's that the creator(s) of CLOWN wrote them to be used to piss off the players.
  21. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Starlord in "Neat" Pictures   
  22. Like
    Grailknight got a reaction from Duke Bushido in The Great Transfer Debate   
    Hadn't noticed the Trigger requirement before and have been building it without it. Hero Designer doesn't flag it, but I suppose that's beyond the scope of the program's checks. The issue of not being able to Aid more than was Drained was just assumed as part of the Linked.
  23. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Christopher R Taylor in The Great Transfer Debate   
    OK so here's the example of how to build Transfer given in Volume One of the Hero System Rules:
     
     
    Now notice in that build: its two powers linked together... with a trigger.  Why on earth have a trigger?
     
    Because in the linked rules, it states this:
     
     
    Aid is an adjustment power, which in this case Steve is treating as an attack power: you have to roll to hit someone who doesn't want to be Aided, so it can kind of be treated as one. Since the Drain is on one target and the Aid is on another (you) then it has to have a mechanism to go off in addition to aid, by that logic.
     
    This is where we part ways.
     
    -First off, you do not need to roll to hit a willing target, per the rules.
    -Second, if your "target" is Self Only (-1) then its not a targeting power at all nor an attack power.  It literally cannot be used on anything but you.
    -Third, the purpose of this build is to simulate the Transfer power, which means it should be as clean and simple as possible to get the build across for ease of use.
    -Fourth, you can use any of your powers on your own phase without needing a trigger to do so.
    -Fifth you are fixated on Aid being an attack power, you could treat this as a Multiple attack in which you use several attack powers on any number of targets (including yourself) in the same attack action.
     
    I could go on, but I think you get the point.  Its a linked power, not a trigger.  That's pointlessly increasing the cost and complication of the power to no good end.
     
    Plus, there should be a small limitation on the Aid noting that it cannot Aid more than you drained.
  24. Haha
    Grailknight reacted to mattingly in Funny Pics II: The Revenge   
  25. Like
    Grailknight reacted to Old Man in What Have You Watched Recently?   
    Replying to my own post--I didn't know this when I saw it, but Godzilla Minus One was filmed on a budget of $15M.  That's almost incomprehensible considering the product that made it to the screen.  It should probably win the effects Oscar based on this fact alone.
×
×
  • Create New...